diff --git a/cartridges/store/managers/steam_api_manager.py b/cartridges/store/managers/steam_api_manager.py
index 6cc2a0d..77656be 100644
--- a/cartridges/store/managers/steam_api_manager.py
+++ b/cartridges/store/managers/steam_api_manager.py
@@ -48,10 +48,16 @@ class SteamAPIManager(AsyncManager):
         appid = additional_data.get("steam_appid", None)
         if appid is None:
             return
+
         # Get online metadata
         try:
             online_data = self.steam_api_helper.get_api_data(appid=appid)
-        except (SteamNotAGameError, SteamGameNotFoundError):
+
+        except SteamGameNotFoundError:
+            return
+
+        except SteamNotAGameError:
             game.update_values({"blacklisted": True})
+
         else:
             game.update_values(online_data)